Are you looking for the best natural-looking mascara for routine usage? If you nod, then you are in the right place. Most women want natural-looking products for everyday makeup and don’t like heavy makeup because heavy makeup is difficult to handle during routine work.
Heavy makeup is only suitable for special occasions like birthday parties, weddings, ceremonies, etc. So, for the women who like no makeup looks of their eyes and want a beautiful natural touch of mascara. We have shortlisted the natural-looking mascaras for them. We have written reviews of them after detailed research and analysis.
The only action you have to take is to discover the best one for you after reading their features, pros, and cons. Our testers and team members found #7 the winning product, #11 the runner-up product, and #9 the most secure product.
Carry on reading to discover the best natural-looking mascara for you.
1. Best Easy-To-Remove Natural-Looking Mascara: Neutrogena Healthy Volume Mascara
This mascara by Neutrogena would give natural volume to your lashes. Its formulation comprises olive oil that would condition and nourish your lashes. Moreover, our testers found that it doesn’t smear and clump. It would give you a natural look in just a single stroke. It is available in the market in 4 different shades to choose your favorite one. It exists in both waterproof and non-waterproof formulations.
Pros
- Exists in 4 shades
- Ophthalmologists tested
- Safe for sensitive eyes
Cons
- May irritate very sensitive eyes
2. Best Nourishing and Natural-Looking Mascara: BareMinerals Love Every Lash Micro Defining Mascara
One of the features which our team chose is its slim brush with tiny bristles that cover the lashes from the roots to the tips and provide uniform coverage. Its brush is also suitable for the bottom and corner lashes. Its formulation is infused with fortifying constituents that condition and nourishes the lashes. It exists in a jet-black shade. Our testers found that it gives perfect natural volume and is suitable for daily use.
- Easy to apply
- With exclusive brush
- Contains nourishing ingredients
Cons
- Many coatings lead to clumps
3. Best Natural-Looking Mascara For Sensitive Eyes: Touch In Sol Paper Pusher Stretch Fiber Lengthening Mascara
The formulation of this mascara is mostly natural and light. Our team members found it appropriate for routine use. Its natural formulation gives natural length and volume to eyelashes. This paper pusher mascara contains black food and carbon black to make the lashes natural-looking and elegant black. It is a long-lasting formula. It is available in the market with a perfectly designed wand having microfiber that combs the lashes well. Our testers also found it easy to remove.
Pros
- Takes no time to wipe off
- Contains silk proteins
- Appropriate for sensitive eyes
Cons
- Not very long-lasting
4. Best Natural-Looking Mascara For All Skin Tones Perricone MD No Mascara Mascara
Our team found this mascara, the user’s favorite one, which urged us to add it to our list of best mascaras. It comprises fortifying constituents like biotin and neuropeptides. It is a 2-in-1 formula that not only conditions and strengthens your eyelashes but also treats them. It would give you fuller natural-looking lashes. Its color is deep black; we found it suitable for all skin shades.
Pros
- With a highly lash-defining brush
- Gives anti-aging lash treatment
- Fortifying formulation
Cons
- Thick application causes clumping
5. Best Lash Strengthening Natural-looking Mascara: Wander Beauty Unlashed Volume and Curl Mascara
This product by Wander beauty comprises a natural and long-lasting formulation. You would get fuller and more voluminous natural-looking lashes. Its wand with fine bristles would separate and coat your lashes from their roots to the tips. Through its dome-tip brush, you can also get a wide range of looks, from delicate to intense. The formulation of this mascara comprises a mixture of lash-caring ingredients like licorice root extracts, peach leaf extracts, and vitamins A, C, and E that help strengthen and condition your lashes to prevent their fall.
Pros
- Synthetic fragrances-free
- Treats and conditions lashes
- With the unique wand
Cons
- Expensive for some of the users
6. Best Ophthalmologist-Tested Natural-Looking Mascara: Clinique Naturally Glossy Mascara
This mascara is a favorite one of those having sensitive eyes and skin. It is available in a sleek silver tube with a long wand that makes its application easy. Its gel-based formulation would give a shiny finish to your lashes. It gives natural volume to eyelashes. Its two colors, jet black and jet brown are available in the market. It is safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.
Pros
- Gives a perfect natural glossy look
- Dermatologists and ophthalmologists approved
- Available in a sleek container
Cons
- Take some time during the application
7. Best Long-lasting Natural-looking Mascara: Ecco Bella FlowerColor Natural Mascara
The formulation of this mascara is vegan-friendly and suitable for routine wear. It has been infused with clay and flowers cutin. This mascara gives fuller lengthy, and natural-looking lashes. It is safe for sensitive eyes. You can wear and remove it safely without eyelash damage. Its exclusively designed brush covers each lash perfectly and keeps them separate. It is clump-free and free from synthetic fragrances and gluten. This mascara is the most natural-looking. Moreover, Its formulation is also long-lasting.
Pros
- Vegan-friendly
- Stays up to a day
- Available in 2 shades
Cons
- Water-resistant but not waterproof
8. Best Hypoallergenic Natural-Looking Mascara: Beautify Beauties Easy On The Eyes Sensitive Mascara
This product is perfect for everyday use. Its formulation is infused with hypoallergenic ingredients and is suitable for sensitive eyes and eyes with contact lenses. Waxes and natural clays have been used during its design process so that it would condition and nourish your lashes. This formula is also extremely pigmented, giving you the desired natural look. It is smudge-free and flake-free. It can be removed easily with soap, water, or a good eye makeup remover.
Pros
- Hypoallergenic
- Natural formula
- Free from synthetic fragrances
Cons
- Gives less lift to lashes
9. Best Cheap Natural-Looking mascara: Maybelline New York Lash Discovery Waterproof Mascara
This product by Maybelline has a unique lash-combing brush to get separated and natural voluminous lashes and forms no clumping. You would get desired natural curl and length with a few of its strokes. It is a water-resistant and washable formula. It has been tested by ophthalmologists and is safe for sensitive eyes and skin. It is easy to wipe off with your favorite mascara remover.
Pros
- Cheap
- Appropriate for contact lens wearers
- Water-resistant
Cons
- Takes time while applying
10. Best Even Application Natural Looking: Covergirl Clump Crusher Mascara
This mascara by Covergirl gives natural-looking volume and fuller natural length despite its claim of giving massive volume attainable after many sweeps. Its wand with fine bristles builds volume without clumping. Its wand is designed uniquely to cover lashes uniformly and keep them separate. It is available in different shades, so you can select your choice according to the color of your lashes. It is free from talc, mineral oil, phthalates, sulfates, etc.
Pros
- Vegan-friendly
- Non-toxic
- Gives the desired volume
Cons
- Takes 3-5 coats for uniform coverage
11. Best Ultra-Conditioning And Natural Looking Mascara: IT Cosmetics Tightline 3-in-1 Black Primer – Eyeliner – Mascara
This product is a 3-in-1 formula because this product acts as a lash primer, eyeliner, and mascara. So, you can enhance the beauty of your eyes with a single product. This product is infused with peptides. It has been designed by plastic surgeons and covers the lashes evenly from their roots to tips. It would give your lashes fuller natural length. The formulation of this product comprises amino acids, antioxidants, biotin, jojoba, collagen, chamomile, etc. It nourishes and conditions the lashes. Unlike your normal mascaras, the innovative thin brush coats even the first quarter of the eyelashes to give an elegant curl and natural volume. Our tester found that applying a layer of primer before wearing mascara may enhance the look of your eyelashes.
Pros
- 3-in-1
- Contains nourishing ingredients
- Suitable for daily usage
Cons
- Having a strong smell
12. The Best Gentle Natural-Looking Mascara: Aliver 4D Silk Fiber Lash Natural Mascara
This clump-free formulation gives natural volume to eyelashes in a single coat. This smooth and soft mascara boosts the natural length of lashes and makes your eye makeup gorgeous. It is a long-lasting formula that stays up to a day. It is water-resistant and sweat-proof mascara but can be removed easily with warm luke water. Our testers and team members found it safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.
Pros
- Soft and silky
- Easy to remove
- Flake or clump-free
Cons
- Dries early to some extent
13. Best Refreshing And Natural Looking Mascara: Tarte Cosmetics Gifted Amazonian Clay Smart Mascara
The application of this mascara provides high-defining lashes. This mascara will be a good choice if you want natural-looking lashes. Our tester found it perfect for everyday use. It strengthens and conditions dry and delicate lashes. It treats the lashes and also makes them voluminous and lengthy. Its formula is infused with vitamin C, Provitamin B5, Carnauba wax, Amazonian clay, rice bran wax, etc., that refresh the skin and eyes. Our team members found that a fine brush should be used for its application to avoid excess application.
Pros
- Nourishes and strengthens the lashes
- Appropriate for daily use
- Refreshes your eyelashes
Cons
- Heavy to a small extent
14. Best Hypoallergenic Natural-Looking Mascara: Glossier Lash Slick Natural Looking Mascara
This mascara is easy to apply and requires a little care while applying. It adds natural length and volume to your lashes and does not clump. It has been made using tiny fibers. This product gives a natural curl and then keeps the curl in place. The formulation of this product is water-resistant, not waterproof, so this can be wiped off with warm luke. It is recommended you not try to use warm water while wearing mascara because, being water resistant, it would take off. It does not irritate sensitive eyes and eyes having contact lenses.
Pros
- Free of paraben
- Hypoallergenic
- Dermatologists
Cons
- Require care and time while applying
15. Best Lash- Lifting Natural Looking Mascara: Benefit Cosmetics Roller Lash Super Curling & Lifting Mascara
This product by Benefit Cosmetics is available in the market in attractive packaging with Hook ‘n’ Roll wand. Its wand would act as a roller for your eyelashes which would help in lifting and separating your lashes. This mascara would give long-lasting lift and curl to your lashes. Its formula comprises provitamin B5 and serin that would condition your lashes and give them a good finish. Due to its long-lasting nature, repetitive touch-ups are not required.
Pros
- Long lasting
- Water-resistant formula
- Contain conditioning ingredients
Cons
- May irritate sensitive eyes and skin
16. Best Clump-free, Natural-Looking Mascara: Neutrogena Healthy Volume Mascara
The formulation of this product contains natural ingredients like olive oil and sweet almond oil that nourish and condition the lashes. Our testers found it smudge-proof and clump-free. It defines the eyelashes perfectly. It is available in 3 colors. It creates a natural-looking volume of lashes. It is not waterproof but can resist water. It is an affordable product for about everyone. Our testers do not find it cruelty-free.
Pros
- Clump-free
- Cheap
- Long-lasting
Cons
- May be drying
Things to be considered while buying natural-looking mascara
These things should be considered when choosing mascara.
Ingredients
While buying mascara, you should look for its beneficial ingredients like vitamins and nourishing or conditioning oils.
The Shape Of Brush
The shape of the brush plays an important role in giving your lashes a natural look. Different mascaras are available in the market, having different shapes and sizes. You would opt for the mascara with a brush that would give natural volume and length to your lashes.
Lightweight product
The formulation of your chosen product should be lightweight and clump-free. Lightweight wear is necessary because heavy products may cause your lashes to go down.
How Can I Make My Mascara Look Natural?
It will be best if you opt for a mascara that may be clump-free or flake-free. To get the natural look of lashes, you should not apply more than three strokes. Don’t use expired or old products that may dry up and flake immediately after usage and make your eyes look awful. For routine usage, it is recommended you not use a primer.
We have shortlisted here; the mascaras that are clump-free and give natural length and volume to the lashes. You can select your favorite one. Many of these are safe for sensitive eyes and skin. Contact lens wearers also use them.
Frequently Asked Questions
What causes mascara to clump?
Many reasons cause mascara to clump, like rapid application, many coats of the product, mascara application on non-primed lashes, and too much product on the wand, so you should clean your wand before applying.
What is the safest mascara to use?
The safest mascara to wear is one that has a hypoallergenic, non-irritant, fragrance-free formulation. It should have eyelash-conditioning ingredients.
Can I put water in my mascara?
No, despite putting water into the mascara tube, you should keep that tube in a glass with warm water. So, your dried-up mascara may become soft and smooth.
Why would you trust us?
You can trust us because we write for you after deep research and analysis. The author is a makeup lover and consults a makeup professional before writing. Besides this, our team and testers also test several of the products on their own and find pros and cons. In short, after painstaking efforts, we provide you with lists and features of the products.
Final verdict
Many women, both housewives and working women around the globe want the natural or no-makeup look of their eyes for everyday wear because heavy daily makeup is difficult to handle during work. Suppose you are one of them looking for natural-looking mascara for no makeup look. We are here to assist you. Here we provide a list and features of the 16 best natural-looking mascaras. You can get the right one by reading their features. We found #7, the winning item, #11, runner-up, and #9, the cheap.
