Are you looking for the best eye makeup remover that would remove you? If your answer is yes, you are at the right place. There is no doubt in it that long-lasting makeup is beneficial because it is smudge-proof, fade-proof, and stays on for a long period. But the removal of long-lasting eye makeup is challenging. You would have to rub the delicate skin around your eyes to remove mascara, so for easy makeup removal, you may use a good makeup remover that would not damage your sensitive skin. The formulation of makeup removers can easily dissolve the makeup without troubling your skin.
Here we provide a list and features of the 16 best mascara removers. We have done deep research and analysis and find the below items very effective. According to research, #15 is the winning product, #7 is the runner-up, and #10 is the safest mascara remover. You can select the product of your own choice by reading features.
You can also get list of best mascaras for yourself!
Carry on reading to discover the best for you.
1. Overall Best Mascara Remover: Mary Kay Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover Plus Eye-Shooting Gel
This product is overall the best makeup remover we found after testing. It is a lightweight product. It would gently remove your mascara. It would leave traces of makeup or oil residues. Before, you would have to shake the bottle of this product to mix the ingredients, then apply the liquid inside the bottle on a cotton pad and wipe off your mascara. This product is appropriate for all types of skin. We found it safe for contact lens wearers and women having sensitive eyes. This packaging includes a gel that would soothe your eyes. Ophthalmologists and dermatologists have tested it. Avoid its contact with the internal area.
Pros
Removes quickly and gently
Does not leave oil remains
It doesn’t irritate the sensitive area around the eyes
Cons
Expensive
2. Cheap Mascara remover: Neutrogena Oil-Free Liquid Eye Makeup Remover
If you are looking for a makeup remover at an affordable price, this product would be a good option for you. Its product is a bi-phase liquid that would dissolve eye makeup without irritating sensitive areas around the eyes. This very effective formulation would remove mascara thoroughly without leaving behind the mascara residues. Our testers found it comfortable for sensitive eyes and skin. It doesn’t cause excess oil on the skin. But you must avoid its contact with the inner eye.
Pros
Affordable
Soft and gentle
Doesn’t irritate eyes
Cons
Leave some residues of oils
3. Best Nourishing mascara remover: Tata Harper Nourishing Makeup Removing Oil Cleanser
Our team found this cleansing oil very effective for removing eye makeup, especially mascara. This oily product can efficiently dissolve oil-based makeup. For its usage, cotton pads it not very necessary. You can apply this product to your hands and massage it around the area of your eyes. It would not only remove the long-lasting and waterproof mascara but also remove the eye shadow. It takes a little bit more time to remove makeup thoroughly and gently. It comes in an elegant glass container, but some users found its pump somewhat faulty. This item will be a good option if you want a mascara remover that may remove your stubborn and waterproof mascara.
Pros
Smooth and luxurious
Nourishing formula
Suitable for oily skin
Cons
Expensive
4. Best Waterproof Mascaras Remover: Nivea Eye Make-Up Remover Double Effect
If you don’t like heavy skin care items, you would like to use this makeup remover. This formulation is lightweight and removes stubborn makeup quickly. One of our testers used only two drops of this product and removed the makeup thoroughly. The users also feel their skin soft and fresh. Some users found that the product gave a greasy touch after its usage. So, we recommend you wash your face with a good face wash after using this makeup remover. To wipe mascara, you can use this product on lashes, but you must avoid contact with the area of the eyes under the lids.
Pros
Quickly removes
Removes waterproof mascaras
Lightweight product
Cons
Some users may feel greasy after its usage
5. Best Soothing Mascara Remover: Laura Mercier Soothing Eye Makeup Remover
This liquid product would not only mascara but also remove eye-shadow and eyeliner. It will wipe off the stubborn makeup in no time. The formulation of this product includes cornflower, which would give you a soothing effect after its usage. This formulation would remove your mascara quickly. It would leave no makeup residue and clean your makeup-wearing parts thoroughly. Many users found this product soft, gentle, non-greasy, and highly efficient. You can apply this product on your hands or cotton pads and put it on your eyelashes to remove your mascara, but you must avoid its contact with internal area of your eyes under your eyelids.
Pros
Gives soothing effect
Non-greasy
It doesn’t leave residues
Cons
Take time while removing waterproof mascara
6. Best Hydrating Mascara remover: e.l.f Cosmetics Holy Hydration! Makeup Melting Cleansing Balm
This makeup-melting cleansing balm would melt off your makeup. Many users found this product very satisfying and effective. This product would work well and remove your mascara and other makeup. You need not tug your skin while removing. The formula of this product is infused with ceramides and hyaluronic acid to hydrate your skin. Its creamy texture boosts hydration but does not leave oil residues on the application area. This product is available at an affordable price.
Pros
Affordable
Hydrating product
Soft and gentle
Cons
Comprises polyethylene
7. Best Mascara Remover With Removing Pads: Marcelle Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover Pads
This product is available in the market with 85 pads to remove the makeup effectively. The pads are soaked into this Marcelle product, and then these pads are used to wipe off makeup. This product would remove your makeup and mascara, and you would not feel over-drying or greasy after its usage. Our team members found that pads are only saturated with the product and don’t contain excessive product on them to prevent dripping of the product into the eyes. This product is fragrance-free and safe for sensitive skin. Dermatologists have tested it. You must use it carefully for mascara and other eye makeup removal.
Pros
Fragrance-free
Dermatologist-tested
It doesn’t leave residues on the face
Cons
Take time while removing mascara
8. Best Clean Mascara Remover: Caudalie Vinoclean Makeup Removing Cleansing Oil
If you’re looking for a clean makeup remover or mascara remover, this cleansing product would be a solid option. This cleansing oil is formulated with castor oil, sunflower oil, grape seed oil, and sweet almond oil. It would dissolve your mascara very efficiently. This product has a rich texture, but our testers felt non-greasy after its usage. You must apply this product on the cotton pads or your hands and swipe across the lashes to get the mascara off. We found this product very effective against waterproof mascaras.
Pros
Removes the mascaras softly and gently
Non-greasy
Contain nourishing ingredients
Cons
It takes time while remove the waterproof formula
- Best Mascara Remover Balm: Drunk Elephant Slaai Makeup Melting Butter Cleanser
This makeup remover balm cares about your skin. Its buttery formulation moisturizes your dry skin. It has an oily formula. For mascara removal, the balm is put on a cotton pad to wipe off the mascara gently. You must avoid its entrance into the internal area of the eye. It is available in semi-solid form. So it doesn’t get into the eyes readily. For face makeup removal, you may remove your makeup only by using a balm or by using exfoliating powder in conjunction with balm. The exfoliating powder is present in the packaging and would give your face extra cleansing. The packaging also contains a spoon. You would have to use the spoon to dish out enough balm. Besides this, the spoon also prevents product contamination by dirty fingers. This product comprises Ingredients like Blueberry extract, Strawberry extract, Acai fruit oil, Watermelon seed oil, Kiwi extract, Cranberry seed oil, etc. So, this product has a fruit-like smell. No synthetic fragrance has been added. The natural ingredients in this product are beneficial, especially for individuals having very sensitive skin. If you are irritated by a fruit-like fragrance, you can take it once for testing.
Pros
Gives deep cleansing
2 in 1 product
Contains natural ingredients
Cons
Has fruity fragrance
10. Best Natural Mascara remover: Cetaphil Gentle Waterproof Makeup Remover
Everything Cetaphil creates recognized for being very soft and smooth. This makeup remover would remove eye makeup, including waterproof mascara remover also do so. The formulation is gentle on the skin. It would remove the face makeup and mascara thoroughly without leaving any residue. You will feel your skin moisturized. It would condition your skin and lashes. It contains organic constituents like aloe vera, green tea botanicals, and ginseng. This remover would remove mascara easily and doesn’t seep into the internal eye area. But care must be taken while applying it on your lashes to avoid contact with the inner eye. Our team members found that it can remove makeup in a single swipe.
Pros
Fragrance-free
Contains organic ingredients
Suitable for sensitive skin
Cons
Well-shaking is required before use
11. Best gentle mascara remover: Garnier SkinActive Micellar Cleansing Water
The eye is the most sensitive area on the face; according to ophthalmologists, constant scrubbing can lead to irritation and loss of lashes. This cleansing water will be a solid option if you are conscious of your eyes and lashes. This product would remove your mascara gently and easily. You would not have to do excessive scrubbing while removing. This cleansing water would clean your skin thoroughly without leaving makeup or dirt residue. This gentle mascara remover would also work best for waterproof mascara.
Pros
Inexpensive
Suitable for waterproof mascara
Removes thoroughly
Cons
It might irritate very sensitive eyes
12. Best Comforting Mascara Remover: CeraVe Eye Makeup Remover
This eye makeup remover makes removing whole eye makeup, including mascara, very easy. Its formulation has been infused with a mixture of very safe ingredients for the eyes. This product contains the ingredients such as ceramics and hydrating hyaluronic acid that would protect your skin. This product includes oil and water formulation that would work well to remove the eye makeup thoroughly and gently. Ophthalmologists have tested it.
Pros
Contact skin-protecting ingredients
Ophthalmologists-tested
Contain non-toxic ingredients
Cons
Dilute product, so take care to avoid its seeping into eyes
13. Best Oil-Based Mascara Remover: Clinique Take The Day Off Cleansing Balm
This eye makeup remover is a solid option for women having dry skin. This multifunctional product is moisturizing and conditioning. Its formula is infused with safflower oil, i.e., an emollient for skin and lashes. Despite having oil, you would not experience a greasy feel. This product is fragrance-free. It has been tested for allergy and is a good option for women having sensitive skin. For gentle mascara removal, put on balm on a cotton pad and then wipe off the mascara with this pad.
Pros
It doesn’t seep into the eyes
Also, remove face makeup
Keeps skin moisturized and smooth
Cons
It might irritate very sensitive eyes
14. Best Mascara Remover Wipes: Cetaphil Gentle Makeup Removing Face Wipes
This product contains 25 water-based wipes in a single package. If you feel anxious to remove your eye makeup by scrubbing with a makeup remover, you can buy these wipes for gentle and easy removal. It would remove your whole eye makeup, including stubborn waterproof mascara. This product has been approved as safe by ophthalmologists for areas around the eyes. It is free from fragrance and parabens. It comprises vitamin E, aloe vera extract, and glycerin that nourishes and moisturizes your lashes and skin. These wipes can remove not only eye makeup but also entire face makeup. It contains ingredients like chamomile extract and green tea extract that would relieve you from inflammation and soothe acne, respectively.
Pros
Removes makeup in no time
Suitable for removal of waterproof mascara
Contain nourishing ingredients
Cons
Generates more waste than single makeup remover
15. Best Mascara Remover For Sensitive Skin: Bioderm Sensibio H2o Soothing Micellar Cleansing Water
This mascara remover by Bioderma is liquid and suitable for sensitive skin. Anyone can use it, from teenagers to adults. It is alcohol-free and paraben-free. For mascara removal, you would have to put on this liquid formulation on a cotton pad, keep it on the eyelashes, and then wipe it off smoothly. This liquid would magically remove the mascara waterproof stubborn mascara in no time.
Pros
Suitable for sensitive skin
Removes mascara instantly
Gives thorough cleansing
16. Best Fragrance-Free Mascara Remover: Respectissime Waterproof Eye Makeup Remover
This eye makeup remover is ophthalmologist-tested and fragrance-free. This gentle product has a water-like texture. It would remove the mascara without excessive rubbing or scrubbing. Our testers found it non-irritating for sensitive eyes. It is a bi-phase formula, so you must shake it well before use. For use, apply it on a cotton pad and gently wipe your lashes with this cotton pad. It has been tested for allergy. It is a paraben-free formula.
Pros
Ophthalmologists and dermatologists tested
Remove mascara in no time
Appropriate for sensitive eyes
Cons
It gives a somewhat oily feel
Guidelines To Buy An Eye Makeup Remover
Choose An Eye Makeup Remover According To Your Skin Type
Different makeup removers are available in markets in different forms, such as oils, balms, wipes, bi-phase solutions, micellar water, etc. Our testers found that the oil cleansers and balms would be suitable for dry skin and stubborn waterproof makeup removal. Individuals who want products that would remove the makeup instantly would go for wipes. Individuals with dry skin may go for micellar water or oil-free makeup removers. For sensitive skin and eyes, ophthalmologist-tested, allergy-tested, and dermatologist-tested removers should be bought.
Ingredients
You must avoid using eye makeup removers that contain parabens, benzalkonium chloride, sulfates, etc. These preservatives may be harmful to the internal part of the eyes. Use the removers that contain nourishing, conditioning, non-toxic and safe ingredients. You should also avoid the removers having fragrance if you have sensitive eyes. It is because the fragrance might be allergenic and irritating.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best way to remove eye makeup?
Remove the eye makeup gently by keeping in mind the sensitivity of the eyes. You must use a high-quality eye makeup remover. Put your selected removing product on a cotton pad, then use it smoothly to wipe off your makeup. The remover would loosen your stubborn and waterproof makeup and prevent you from excessive scrubbing. You may repeat this process if you don’t get thorough cleansing in the first wipe.
What can I do if I get eye makeup remover in my eyes?
If an eye makeup remover gets into your eyes, you should immediately go for washing your eyes with good quality eyewash. If you still feel discomfort, consult your doctor and follow his instruction.
Can I rub my eyes to remove my makeup?
You should not rub your eyes to remove makeup. The eye is the most delicate area on your face so that rubbing may cause redness and swelling. Always go for the best makeup remover and remove the makeup gently and smoothly.
Why Should You Trust Us?
We shortlist the products for deep research and testing. The author is a makeup enthusiast and loves to use and write about makeup products. We test several of the products before recommending them. Our team members also consult makeup professionals and users about the products. We also see reviews about the product on different online platforms.
Final Verdict
Many women look for the best eye makeup remover for their stubborn and waterproof makeup. If you’re one of them, we can help you here. We are providing you with a list of the best makeup removers. We have discussed their features too. Our discussion would help you discover the best one for you. You would have to read the features of the provided products to select the one that may suit your skin and eyes. Our shortlisting is based on detailed research and analysis. We found #1 the winning product, # 7 the runner-up, and #10 the safest.
